Top 9 Best Restaurants in Bimini Bahamas! The Serene Islands BEST Eateries!
In this guide, I’ll share my picks for the top restaurants in Bimini—these Bimini best eateries are sure to satisfy your cravings and give you a true taste of island life.
Navigating the dining scene in Bimini can be surprisingly challenging—especially if you’re wondering where to find local food in Bimini or searching for those hidden culinary gems.
Many of the best restaurants in Bimini are tucked away in unexpected places, making them easy to miss if you don’t know where to look.
That’s why I’ve put together this comprehensive list of top Bimini Bahamas restaurants.
Whether you’re after authentic island flavors or simply want to know where to eat in Bimini, this guide will make it easy for you to discover the island’s best eateries and plan your next unforgettable meal.
The Restaurants
CJ’s Deli (With Beach Access)
CJ’s is a true hidden gem among Bimini restaurants, and as a family-owned spot, it stands out for its warm, attentive service—a rarity on the island.
Located in Alice Town, CJ’s serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, making it a reliable choice any time of day.
While the menu is on the smaller side, every dish is prepared fresh and full of authentic flavor.
We can’t recommend the Lobster and Conch enough—they’re absolutely outstanding and a must-try for any visitor.
A quick tip: The dining area is cozy, so larger groups (more than four) may find space a bit tight. And don’t miss the fresh coconuts on the beach—they’re a refreshing bonus that adds to the local experience.
Three Daughters Deli
At Three Daughters Deli, you can truly have your meal just the way you like it. This spot is known for its versatility, offering everything from hearty sandwiches and wraps to indulgent lobster, shrimp, and lamb plates.
The heart of their menu is home-cooked comfort—each dish is prepared with care, capturing that authentic, homemade taste. Even the appetizers and wings stand out, making it a great place to start your meal or enjoy a casual bite. If you’re looking for a welcoming atmosphere and a diverse selection of delicious options, Three Daughters Deli is a must-visit in Bimini.
Whether you’re craving local seafood or classic favorites, you’re sure to leave satisfied.
Edith’s Pizza
Whether you’re craving a classic cheese pizza or something more adventurous, Edith’s is a must-visit in Bimini. The dough strikes a perfect balance—savory with a hint of sweetness—complementing every topping and making each bite memorable.
In our opinion, Edith’s serves up the best pizza on the island.
Service here is attentive and friendly, and the restaurant’s beachside location offers stunning views that enhance the whole experience.
Beyond pizza, the wings, fries, and fish are all cooked to perfection—crispy, fresh, and full of flavor.
For anyone visiting Bimini, we recommend making Edith’s your first stop. It’s the perfect way to kick off your island food adventure.
Bimini Big Game Resort Bar & Grill (Formerly known as “Sharkies”)
Bimini Big Game has you covered for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, offering everything from classic morning fare to specialty lunch dishes and memorable sunset dinners.
The menu is extensive, so there’s something for everyone.
Even our son kept reminding us of the Lobster Mac & Cheese days later!
Our top picks were the Coconut Shrimp and the Grilled Mahi Filet—both highly recommended.
Keep in mind, service here moves at a relaxed island pace, so settle in and enjoy the atmosphere. Prices are on the higher side, but the wide variety of options makes it worth a visit.
Charlie’s Bread
Charlie’s Bread is easily one of our top picks in Bimini. There’s almost always a line out the door, but trust us—it’s absolutely worth the wait.
If you’re tempted to think, “It’s just bread,” you’ll be pleasantly surprised. The Cinnamon Roll bread was a standout favorite—truly unforgettable.
The coconut bread was unlike anything we’ve ever tasted, packed with unique island flavor.
We missed out on the Guava bread because it sold out early, but it’s definitely on our list for next time.
Charlie, the baker, pours genuine passion and care into every loaf he makes, and it shows in every bite. In fact, if you stop by early in the morning, you’ll likely see Charlie himself, hard at work in the bakery—mixing, kneading, and baking with the same dedication day after day.
His presence and commitment are the heart of this local spot, and you can taste that devotion in every loaf/slice.
If you’re in Bimini, make sure to stop by Charlie’s Bread—it’s a must-visit for any food lover.
The Rum Bar (AKA “Healing Hole”)
Conveniently situated at the entrance of Fisherman’s Village, The Rum Bar quickly became one of our favorite dining spots in Bimini. The location makes it an easy stop whether you’re just arriving or looking for a quick bite during your day of exploring.
While the menu is straightforward with just nine items, every dish is impressively fresh and flavorful.
We especially recommend trying the Fisherman’s Catch and the Back Yard Fried Chicken—both are standouts that showcase the quality and care put into each meal.
One thing to keep in mind: The Rum Bar operates on limited hours, which can make it tricky to catch them open.
Be sure to check their schedule and plan your visit for opening time to avoid missing out on this local gem.
Stuart’s Conch Stand
Bimini’s heat can be intense, and the Passionfruit Radler salad at Stuarts is the perfect way to cool off and refresh. But what truly sets Stuarts apart is their expertise in conch—this spot elevates the island’s signature delicacy to a whole new level.
If you’re serious about experiencing the best conch in Bimini, Stuarts is a must-visit. The staff are welcoming, the ambiance is inviting, and every dish highlights why conch is such a beloved part of local cuisine.
From start to finish, Stuarts delivers an outstanding conch experience that stands out on the island.
Joe’s Conch Stand
Joe’s, much like Stuarts, has truly made a name for itself with its exceptional conch dishes—you really can’t go wrong with either spot if you’re craving this island specialty.
What sets Joe’s apart, though, is their standout fried fish. It was a real highlight of our visit—flavorful, fresh, and, dare I say, phenomenal. The combination of expertly prepared conch and perfectly fried fish makes Joe’s a must-visit for anyone looking to sample the best of Bimini’s local cuisine.
If you’re exploring where to eat in Bimini, don’t miss Joe’s. You won’t regret stopping by for a meal that’s packed with island flavor and local charm.
Joe’s received the second best ranking on Trip Advisor. See the reviews here!
Smitty’s Beach Bar & Restaurant
Smitty’s is the place to go if you want fantastic views of Bimini’s pristine waters while listening to music and soaking in the island vibe.
The seafood platter is a must-try, and the conch fritters and shrimp are local favorites. The menu is simple and focused on the essentials, making it easy to find a classic island meal.
Just keep in mind that service can be slow, so plan to relax and enjoy the scenery while you wait.
Conclusion
Bimini might be a small island, but its food scene is packed with unforgettable flavors and unique dining experiences. From hidden gems serving up the best local seafood to beachfront spots with unbeatable views, the best restaurants in Bimini truly offer something for every traveler.
Whether you’re searching for where to eat in Bimini, craving fresh conch, or eager to discover Bimini’s best eateries, this list is your starting point for an incredible culinary adventure.
Bon appétit and happy travels!
Transportation Pro Tip
If you’re arriving in Bimini by cruise, there’s a convenient tram that will bring you straight into town and drop you off at Fisherman’s Village (Marina).
My top recommendation for getting around the island is to rent a golf cart—this made a huge difference on our second trip. While the golf cart vendors can be persistent, having your own cart is absolutely essential for exploring all that Bimini’s seven-mile stretch has to offer.
Just a heads up: driving is on the left side of the road, so be prepared before you set off on your island adventure!
Is There Shopping in Bimini, Bahamas?
Absolutely! While Bimini is a small island, it offers a unique and authentic shopping experience thanks to its vibrant local community. The island is known for its rich cultural immersion, with most shops and markets run by locals. You’ll find everything from lively straw markets and handmade crafts to clothing boutiques and souvenir shops—perfect for picking up a special memento or gift.
That said, many visitors find it challenging to locate the best shopping spots, as they’re often tucked away and not always easy to discover on your own. Local recommendations are invaluable for navigating Bimini’s shopping scene and making the most of your visit.
About the Author:
Kam is a passionate traveler with a decade of cruising experience, having explored the world by sea for over ten years.
He has immersed himself in the unique offerings of all the major cruise lines, from popular favorites to luxury experiences.
Kam’s journeys span Virgin Voyages, Celebrity Cruises, Princess, Carnival, Royal Caribbean, Oceania, MSC, and many more you’re sure to recognize.
His firsthand knowledge and love for adventure bring a seasoned, insightful perspective to every travel story he shares.